Salaam alaikum Cycads,
You ought to have a email link on your site somewhere so people can communicate with you administratively.
Along those lines, I figured you might be interested in speaking out against the National Fatwa Council of Malaysia’s fatwa against tomboyism (assuming you disagree with it).
By the way, love your site. I too found it through MMW and now check in regularly to see what’s new. Yours is a very cool voice in the mix of the Islamsphere.
Thanks for the link! I find it outrageous that there’s even fatwa against so-called ‘tomboy-ism’! Firstly, being a tomboy is completely subjective – from having really short hair, liking sports, finding boys smelly, not liking pink and make-up, or generally just being a little on the rough side can all go into the tomboy basket.
Secondly, perhaps fear of women behaving like men, and thus possessing qualities undeserving of women i.e. defying authority/patriarchy underlies this fatwa.
And lastly, this idea that tomboy-ism and alleged lesbianism is really about the intolerance towards this evil and non-existent thing called female sexuality. This reminds me about the case many years ago of two women, Rohana and Azizah, getting married in Malaysia. Before they made the headlines, the ‘tomboy’ of the two (can’t remember which one) disguised as a man in order to get married.
Their marriage was eventually annulled, the tomboy was ‘rehabilitated’ into becoming a ‘normal’ woman, and later made the news again after declaring that she intends to marry a man and confessed that she had led her former partner on. All of this got a lot of attention unlike a quickly forgotten news story soon after about two men getting married in secret.
Thanks for the kind comments, Tim. “Life with a Japanese wife” does sound interesting! My boyfriend should write something like that. But I’m quite sure that it’ll read like a Gothic horror story.
I appreciate your post about Malaysian mail-order brides. I…tend to be a very vocal opponent of mail-order marriage. Nothing could be more mercenary and delusional. To me, it’s a sign of incompetence and cowardice.
saya sudah baca artikel saudari di merdeka review. secara prinsipnya, saya bersetuju dengan isi tulisan saudari dan terutamanya tatacara agensi-agensi kerajaan menangani ‘hu-ha-hu-ha’ penganjuran seksualiti merdeka serta tuduhan-tuduhan liar yang melampau seperti ‘pesta seks bebas’ dsb. yang mana telah mengakibatkan objektif pengajuran SM yang dimulakan pada 2008 itu telah dipesongkan 360 darjah dan saya masih lagi berfikir, siapakah yang mendapat keuntungan dengan segala mak nenek riuh rendah ini.
dan, perkasa sekali membuktikan kejaguhan rasisma mereka dan istiqamah menjadi jaguh pula dalam mewujudkan ‘ketegangan yang tidak perlu’ dalam pola kemasyarakatan majmuk tanahair yang sudah sedia dan senantiasa kacau dengan konflik politik PR-BN.
I JS CAME ACROSS UR BLOG 2DE WHILE LOOKIN 4 FEMINISM ARTICLES IN MSIA.
I WAS V MUCH SURPRISED DT MSIANS DO WRITE ON FEMINISM N VOICE OUT OPINIONS.
IM KEEN 2 READ MORE OF UR ARTICLES
GOOD JOB ANGRY MALAY LADY.
U DO SET A GUD EXAMPLE OF A MODERN WOMEN OF MALAYSIAN S0CIETY =)
i am also a researcher. currently on state feminism….
glad to have people with similar interests because there are way too few people to share thoughts on feminism back home….
Very nice write-ups. Strong point of view that cuts through the skin and makes a patch with the inner soul. Maybe right, maybe wrong; in any case I find the words written with honesty. Works for me.
Now, Lee(my Made In China Puppet crow) & me, we’re going to cover(as in really cover) Malaysia in mid-July and it’d be great to get some perspective from you. Oh and, I’m spectacularly spectacled.
Always find your articles very interesting and well grounded.I send my best wishes thro Greg to you. As a woman who have been in the feminist struggle for decades, it is frustrating for me to realise that such struggles have been quite confined mainly to the urban English educated Middle class women. Did not seep to the working class women,thus preventing the spreading of feminism into a ” movement.” With the backlash of patriachal conservatism, it further impedes understanding of feminism among the general malaysian population. All in all, i wish you the best of luck in your endeavour. Cheers. Rohana
Hi! I just started an instagram page dedicated to Malaysian social issues, particularly for Malaysian women. I am very pleased to have found your blog! I will always reference you of course if I were to take any information from here. I wish you all the best! Hope to see you if you ever areange another feminist gathering.
good blog.
Thank you! I am trying my best to keep this blog going this time.
All the best in your studies and take good care.
PS : Saya mahu link kamu.
Terima kaceh.
ps: boleh
Discovered you through Muslimah Media Watch. DEFINITELY bookmarking you.
Salaam alaikum Cycads,
You ought to have a email link on your site somewhere so people can communicate with you administratively.
Along those lines, I figured you might be interested in speaking out against the National Fatwa Council of Malaysia’s fatwa against tomboyism (assuming you disagree with it).
Story is here:
http://www.progressiveislam.info/showDiary.do?diaryId=900
My own denunciation of it here:
http://www.progressiveislam.info/showDiary.do?diaryId=905
By the way, love your site. I too found it through MMW and now check in regularly to see what’s new. Yours is a very cool voice in the mix of the Islamsphere.
Wassalaam
Salaam,
Thanks for the link! I find it outrageous that there’s even fatwa against so-called ‘tomboy-ism’! Firstly, being a tomboy is completely subjective – from having really short hair, liking sports, finding boys smelly, not liking pink and make-up, or generally just being a little on the rough side can all go into the tomboy basket.
Secondly, perhaps fear of women behaving like men, and thus possessing qualities undeserving of women i.e. defying authority/patriarchy underlies this fatwa.
And lastly, this idea that tomboy-ism and alleged lesbianism is really about the intolerance towards this evil and non-existent thing called female sexuality. This reminds me about the case many years ago of two women, Rohana and Azizah, getting married in Malaysia. Before they made the headlines, the ‘tomboy’ of the two (can’t remember which one) disguised as a man in order to get married.
Their marriage was eventually annulled, the tomboy was ‘rehabilitated’ into becoming a ‘normal’ woman, and later made the news again after declaring that she intends to marry a man and confessed that she had led her former partner on. All of this got a lot of attention unlike a quickly forgotten news story soon after about two men getting married in secret.
Great blog.
Had to comment after reading the comments above and your post on mail order brides.
My wife is Asian (Japanese). She’s not subservient, not demure, totally the opposite of the “Asian-woman stereotype.” She also happens to be a tomboy.
Thought you might be interested in my most recent post, “Life with a Japanese Wife” at japaninsight.wordpress.com
Aloha!
Tim
Thanks for the kind comments, Tim. “Life with a Japanese wife” does sound interesting! My boyfriend should write something like that. But I’m quite sure that it’ll read like a Gothic horror story.
I appreciate your post about Malaysian mail-order brides. I…tend to be a very vocal opponent of mail-order marriage. Nothing could be more mercenary and delusional. To me, it’s a sign of incompetence and cowardice.
Anyways, good day to you.
[smile]…I found your little blog during a good search for clothing style of egyptian and arabic women for a story I’m creating.
Great blog. I love your point of view.
i like your point of view ,i am from Africa (Ethiopia).
You have some really good stuff here. You should tweet your work (but if you already do, pardon my ignorance).
A great and highly queer friendly….Keep writing and keep enlightening us…salam hangat.
Salam;
saya sudah baca artikel saudari di merdeka review. secara prinsipnya, saya bersetuju dengan isi tulisan saudari dan terutamanya tatacara agensi-agensi kerajaan menangani ‘hu-ha-hu-ha’ penganjuran seksualiti merdeka serta tuduhan-tuduhan liar yang melampau seperti ‘pesta seks bebas’ dsb. yang mana telah mengakibatkan objektif pengajuran SM yang dimulakan pada 2008 itu telah dipesongkan 360 darjah dan saya masih lagi berfikir, siapakah yang mendapat keuntungan dengan segala mak nenek riuh rendah ini.
dan, perkasa sekali membuktikan kejaguhan rasisma mereka dan istiqamah menjadi jaguh pula dalam mewujudkan ‘ketegangan yang tidak perlu’ dalam pola kemasyarakatan majmuk tanahair yang sudah sedia dan senantiasa kacau dengan konflik politik PR-BN.
In your drawing, I just realized that “asshole” is “solehah” jumbled up (well, almost anyway!). ;P
Interesting observation. Just don’t let a good Muslim woman (or her quick-tempered husband or father) hear that.
I JS CAME ACROSS UR BLOG 2DE WHILE LOOKIN 4 FEMINISM ARTICLES IN MSIA.
I WAS V MUCH SURPRISED DT MSIANS DO WRITE ON FEMINISM N VOICE OUT OPINIONS.
IM KEEN 2 READ MORE OF UR ARTICLES
GOOD JOB ANGRY MALAY LADY.
U DO SET A GUD EXAMPLE OF A MODERN WOMEN OF MALAYSIAN S0CIETY =)
hi
i am also a researcher. currently on state feminism….
glad to have people with similar interests because there are way too few people to share thoughts on feminism back home….
🙂
Very nice write-ups. Strong point of view that cuts through the skin and makes a patch with the inner soul. Maybe right, maybe wrong; in any case I find the words written with honesty. Works for me.
Now, Lee(my Made In China Puppet crow) & me, we’re going to cover(as in really cover) Malaysia in mid-July and it’d be great to get some perspective from you. Oh and, I’m spectacularly spectacled.
Its been sometime since you’ve written this comment. And I apologise for the lateness. I’m glad that you’ve reading my pieces here 🙂
seronok membaca tulisan saudari… berkembangnya idea pemikiran semasa..!
Oh, bagus sekali! Kembang pula saya mendengarnya.
Wow you’re really angry person. Interesting. Bookmarked.
Always find your articles very interesting and well grounded.I send my best wishes thro Greg to you. As a woman who have been in the feminist struggle for decades, it is frustrating for me to realise that such struggles have been quite confined mainly to the urban English educated Middle class women. Did not seep to the working class women,thus preventing the spreading of feminism into a ” movement.” With the backlash of patriachal conservatism, it further impedes understanding of feminism among the general malaysian population. All in all, i wish you the best of luck in your endeavour. Cheers. Rohana
Excellent blog. Keep it up! –dan s. wang
Hi! I just started an instagram page dedicated to Malaysian social issues, particularly for Malaysian women. I am very pleased to have found your blog! I will always reference you of course if I were to take any information from here. I wish you all the best! Hope to see you if you ever areange another feminist gathering.